Publishers just got their wake-up call. According to AdExchanger, traffic is down 30% or more since ChatGPT and Google’s AI Overviews hit the market. More than half of searches in 2025 don’t lead anywhere—people get answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini without clicking a single link.
The advertising industry’s response? Scramble mode.
The AI Attribution Problem Nobody’s Talking About
While publishers lose traffic to AI, the platforms are doubling down on AI-powered ad tools. Meta announced it’s building an AI-powered search ad product for Facebook and Instagram. Amazon just partnered with iHeartMedia to expand programmatic audio through Amazon DSP, promising natural language campaign creation that lets advertisers describe targeting objectives “using business terminology rather than platform-specific taxonomy.”
Everyone’s selling AI as the solution to the problem AI created.
Here’s what they’re not saying: attribution just got exponentially harder.
When users don’t click through to publisher sites, the entire measurement chain breaks. No page views, no engagement metrics, no clear conversion paths. Brands that built attribution models on user journeys through content are now staring at a black box where ChatGPT answered the question and maybe—maybe—influenced a purchase three weeks later.
The Retail Media Rush
The smart money knows this. IAB Europe released analysis this week showing retail media and CTV converging at speed, hitting $29 billion in global spend (excluding Amazon). Why? Closed-loop measurement. When the customer searches, clicks, and buys all within Amazon or Walmart’s ecosystem, attribution is clean. For now.
Amazon’s expanding its DSP dominance with the iHeartMedia partnership, adding programmatic audio to its arsenal. The company pulled in $17.7 billion in ad revenue last quarter, up 24% year-over-year. Beyond claiming better performance, Amazon’s telling agencies it’s cheaper to buy the open web through their DSP—claiming fees as low as 1% on Programmatic Guaranteed deals compared to an industry average of around 4%.
But even closed-loop isn’t safe. The retail media networks everyone’s celebrating are making the same mistake display advertising made a decade ago: confusing correlation with causation. Just because someone saw your ad and bought your product in the same ecosystem doesn’t mean the ad caused the purchase.
CMO Pressure Intensifies
CMO tenure dropping from 4.1 to 3.9 years tells you everything about the pressure. Fortune 500 companies with CMOs dropped from 63% to 58% in 2025. When measurement gets murky and budgets get questioned, heads roll.
Raja Rajamannar leaving Mastercard after 12 years as chief marketing and communications officer—with Accenture’s Jill Kramer taking over in December—signals the changing of the guard. The industry is eating its veterans.
The Retreat to Nostalgia
Meanwhile, brands are retreating to what worked before. Gushers revived its surreal ’90s “Fruitheads” campaign with a horror film for Halloween. Pringles brought back “Once You Pop” with a slight update: “Once You Pop, The Pop Don’t Stop.” Columbia Sportswear, Tootsie Roll, and Acuvue are all digging into brand archives, tapping existing fandoms instead of taking creative risks.
Nostalgia marketing isn’t strategy. It’s risk aversion dressed up as trend.
Platform Consolidation Accelerates
Meta’s making moves that show where power is consolidating. The company rolled out CTA stickers to more advertisers and launched new ad formats for Threads—static carousels and video ads—for its 400+ million monthly users. But the real story is Meta’s plan to update privacy policies so interactions with Meta AI can inform ad placement decisions in Facebook and Instagram feeds.
Translation: Your conversations with AI chatbots will train the ad algorithm.
Meta’s also banning all political, electoral, and social issue ads in Europe starting this month due to the EU’s Transparency and Targeting of Political Advertising Act. When platforms can’t solve for transparency and regulation simultaneously, they just pull out of verticals entirely.
What This Week Really Means
The real story this week isn’t any single headline. It’s the pattern: AI is forcing the industry to rebuild attribution, measurement, and creative strategy simultaneously. Publishers are losing traffic. Platforms are consolidating power. Brands are clinging to proven creative. CMOs are getting fired faster than ever.
And everyone’s pretending the foundation isn’t cracking beneath their feet.
The winners in 2026 won’t be the ones with the best AI tools. They’ll be the ones who rebuilt their measurement stack to track influence instead of clicks, causation instead of correlation, and brand lift instead of last-touch attribution.
The losers will be the ones still optimizing for traffic that AI search already ate.
Sources: